These forums are a place where Dominion content can be created, revised, and eventually published on the Wake up, Meeples blog. They also serve as a place for discussion and feedback for Making Luck: A Dominion Podcast.

Please or Register to create posts and topics.

Dominion: Menagerie (expansion) First Impressions

It's that time again, a new expansion! That means it's time to collect the hot takes of everyone out there. I opened up a poll, inviting anyone to rate all of the card-shaped objects in Menagerie on a scale of 0 through 10. This post is meant only to present the results of that poll, in a couple of months I'll make another poll to see how things have changed and at that time I'll be sharing my own ratings and where I may disagree.

Here's a link to a spreadsheet with the raw data for this poll, as well as the results I'll be referring to here.

I'll just give a couple of highlights of the data here. The highest rated cards are:

Seize the Day, Bounty Hunter, Mastermind, Way of the Chameleon, and Wayfarer. Bounty Hunter and Mastermind had particularly low variance, which is a good sign for both of them.

The lowest rated cards are:

Ride, Sleigh, Black Cat, and Way of the Mule

The cards with the most disagreement are below, but it's worth noting that all of the Ways have a lot of high variance -- this makes sense because they are a new concept, so they're a lot harder to rate.

Way of the Pig, Cavalry, Populate, and Gamble

That's all for now, check out the spreadsheet if you want more details, and stay tuned for the post in a few months where I'll revisit these ratings and give a bit more commentary!